The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the Trump administration exceeded its legal authority when it withheld $73.5 million in highway funding from New York. The court found that the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) acted outside its statutory powers regarding a dispute over state driver licensing practices. The ruling involves funds that were initially frozen in April 2026.
The conflict began when USDOT officials cited an audit alleging that New York state was routinely issuing commercial driver licenses to foreign drivers who were in the country illegally. In response to these findings, federal authorities ordered the state to revoke specific licenses. When New York officials refused to comply with the federal order, USDOT halted the transportation aid, prompting the state to file a lawsuit.
In its decision, the appeals court stated that the USDOT's actions departed from regulatory text and failed to provide fair notice to the state. The court further noted that the department's justification underestimated the complexity of the requirements it sought to enforce. While the Trump administration argued the measures were necessary for regulatory compliance, New York officials characterized the funding freeze as an act of political bias, similar to legal challenges filed by other states including California.
This ruling affects the state government of New York by addressing $73.5 million in transportation infrastructure funds. The scale of the dispute extended beyond this initial amount, as USDOT had threatened to freeze an additional $147 million in annual aid if the state did not comply with federal licensing demands. The state argued that the loss of these funds imperiled residents and that revoking the contested licenses would disrupt industries reliant on commercial drivers, such as potential bus driver shortages affecting school schedules and families.
The court’s decision addresses the limits of executive power to withhold funds over state-level policy disagreements. This case is part of a series of legal conflicts between the federal government and various states and cities. For example, a judge in March ordered the unfreezing of approximately $3 billion for Chicago rail projects after USDOT halted over $9.5 million in reimbursements. Similar litigation has occurred over the $16 billion Hudson Tunnel rail project and New York City’s congestion pricing plan.
Spokespeople for Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and New York Governor Kathy Hochul did not immediately comment on the ruling. The decision blocks the federal government's current mechanism for penalizing the state's licensing policies, though the audit concerns regarding commercial licenses for foreign drivers remain a point of contention.
