The Plain Record

Neutral daily news — clear headlines, complete facts.

Legal

Costa Rican police arrest two suspects in death of American businessman Kurt Van Dyke

Police in Costa Rica arrested the girlfriend of Kurt Van Dyke and another man on suspicion of murder nine months after the American surfer was killed.

Published November 18, 2026 at 8:50 PM EST

The short answer

Police in Costa Rica arrested the girlfriend of Kurt Van Dyke and another man on suspicion of murder nine months after the American surfer was killed.

Costa Rican police arrest two suspects in death of American businessman Kurt Van Dyke

The Facts

Who
Kurt Van Dyke, his girlfriend (Arroyo), and a man identified as Gutiérrez.
What
The arrest of two suspects in the murder of Kurt Van Dyke.
When
Last week
Where
Puerto Viejo de Talamanca, Costa Rica
Why
Police allege the suspects planned a robbery to obtain bank card PINs linked to Van Dyke's hotel.

Costa Rican authorities arrested two individuals last week in connection with the death of 66-year-old American businessman and surfer Kurt Van Dyke. The suspects, identified by police by their last names, Arroyo and Gutiérrez, face allegations of murder and robbery nine months after Van Dyke was found dead in his home.

Van Dyke, a Santa Cruz, California, native who had lived in Costa Rica since the 1980s, was found stabbed and strangled earlier this year in Puerto Viejo de Talamanca. At the time, he owned a hotel in the coastal town. Arroyo, his 31-year-old girlfriend, was present during the incident but reportedly survived without serious injuries.

According to police, the two suspects allegedly planned a robbery to obtain the personal identification numbers (PINs) for bank cards associated with Van Dyke’s hotel business. The second suspect, Gutiérrez, is a 34-year-old man. The arrests were carried out by heavily armed officers during a nighttime operation.

Peter Van Dyke, the victim's brother, told CBS News that the family found the girlfriend's survival "extremely odd" but refrained from public speculation until the arrests were made. He expressed satisfaction with the progress of the investigation, noting his faith in Costa Rican law enforcement despite the nine-month duration of the inquiry.

The case affects the family and business associates of Kurt Van Dyke, including his three children and his brother, as well as the local surfing community. The legal proceedings involve two Costa Rican residents now in custody, Arroyo and Gutiérrez.

The case centers on the operations of Van Dyke’s hotel and the alleged attempt to seize business bank accounts, though the exact dollar amounts targeted were not reported. Van Dyke’s eldest son plans to travel to Costa Rica for the eventual murder trial.

A specific date for the murder trial has not yet been reported, but the victim's family has indicated they will be present for the proceedings.

Summaries are written by The Plain Record to state the facts of a story plainly and without political slant. Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the source record before publication. See how we report, or report a correction.

← Back to the front page

Questions readers ask

What happened: Costa Rican police arrest two suspects in death of American businessman Kurt Van Dyke?

The arrest of two suspects in the murder of Kurt Van Dyke.

Who is involved?

Kurt Van Dyke, his girlfriend (Arroyo), and a man identified as Gutiérrez.

When did this happen?

Last week

Where did this happen?

Puerto Viejo de Talamanca, Costa Rica

Why does this matter?

Police allege the suspects planned a robbery to obtain bank card PINs linked to Van Dyke's hotel.