Health experts and fitness professionals are advising against the common holiday practice of viewing exercise as a way to "work off" seasonal meals. Nutritionists and gym owners report that the phrase "work it off" can foster a cycle of food moralization and exercise as punishment. This messaging is frequently heard during the period between Halloween and the end-of-year holidays.
The guidance follows observations of common fitness industry practices, such as instructors encouraging participants to burn off specific treats like candy. Experts suggest that these calorie-focused motivations may overlook other documented benefits of physical activity. According to Alyssa Royse, owner of Rocket Community Fitness, linking food to exercise can create a mindset where individuals feel they must "earn" the right to eat or experience pleasure.
Emmie Keefe, a Boston-based nutritionist, stated that exercise should be prioritized for cardiovascular health, mental health, and social relationships rather than calorie counting. Keefe noted that attempting to calculate precise calories in and out through "mental gymnastics" is often unrealistic. Research cited by these experts indicates that regular exercise contributes to longevity and sleep quality, while viewing physical activity as a penalty may decrease a person's likelihood of maintaining the habit.
The scale of this issue involves a widespread cultural pattern where media messaging has historically pushed for thinner body types, according to Royse. While exact figures on how many people use food-based exercise motivation were not reported, the NEDA maintains a national hotline (1-800-931-2237) for those struggling with eating disorders. People who adopt these recommendations would notice a change in their day-to-day internal dialogue, moving toward "mindful eating" where they prioritize hunger and fullness cues over external rules about "earning" meals.
Physically, the knock-on effects of food-shaming can include the release of stress hormones, which Keefe said may lead to stomach pains, digestive problems, headaches, and heart palpitations. By avoiding excessive exercise in anticipation of or reaction to holiday eating, individuals may avoid the decline in overall health that can occur when the body is under extreme stress. Trainers like Royse are now choosing to focus on hydration and movement for physical comfort rather than as a penalty. These recommendations are expected to remain relevant throughout the duration of the holiday season.
