U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued a ruling on Saturday blocking the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park and its historic golf course in Washington, D.C. The order temporarily halts a closure that was scheduled for Sunday, Nov. 15, as part of a White House plan to redesign the site into a championship-style golf course. While the judge barred the closure, she noted that the administration is not required to actively manage the park or the golf course during this period.
The decision stems from a legal challenge brought by a D.C. preservation group and two local golfers. The plaintiffs argued that the administration’s stated reasons for the closure—including safety risks and a deteriorating sea wall—were justifications created to facilitate a redesign by architect Tom Fazio. Judge Reyes characterized the government's arguments as "pretextual," questioning why the park was not closed earlier for repairs if the safety concerns were an emergency, noting that thousands of people ran through the park during the Marine Corps Marathon last month.
President Trump stated on social media Sunday that the administration will file an expedited appeal, describing the course as being in a state of disrepair. A Department of Justice spokesperson stated that the department would defend the administration’s agenda and noted that the court order does not prevent continued planning for the new course. To date, however, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward testified he would be shocked to learn if there was a finalized contract with Fazio for the construction.
The dispute follows a series of recent actions at the site, including the National Park Service (NPS) cutting down more than 500 trees in a single weekend last month. Judge Reyes subsequently blocked further tree removal and required the Justice Department to provide notice of any future actions at the course. Additionally, the judge has opened an inquiry into whether officials from the Interior Department, Justice Department, and NPS misrepresented facts or violated ethics rules during the proceedings.
For the public, the immediate impact is the continued, if limited, access to a park that was hours away from a total shutdown. However, the future of the site remains uncertain. If the administration succeeds in its appeal or completes required reviews, the park could still close. The renovation is expected to open in roughly 15 months. During such a closure, residents would lose access to the site's playground and the riverside loop used by runners and cyclists. The DOJ argued that the NPS must still conduct environmental and historic preservation assessments before any permanent changes begin.
The case also sets a procedural precedent regarding how much deference courts give to executive directives when they conflict with established agency review processes. A Justice Department lawyer argued that "when the president talks, the agencies listen," while the court has focused on whether the agency followed federal law in its decision-making. The next specific step in the approval process is a meeting of the National Capital Planning Commission scheduled for Dec. 3. Judge Reyes also intends to appoint a special master to investigate potential government misconduct in the case, a move the Justice Department opposes.