The state of Florida is scheduled to execute Thomas Mitchell Overton on Thursday, November 19, 2026, for the 1991 murders of Michael and Susan “Missy” MacIvor. Overton, 71, is set to receive a three-drug lethal injection at 6 p.m. at Florida State Prison in Raiford. This execution follows his 1999 conviction on two counts of first-degree murder, sexual battery, and burglary.
The case stems from the deaths of Michael MacIvor, 30, and Susan MacIvor, 29, who was eight months pregnant at the time. Their bodies were discovered on August 22, 1991, at their home in Tavernier in the Florida Keys. Investigators found that the phone lines had been cut and the intruder had entered through a second-floor window. The unborn child did not survive the attack.
The case remained unsolved for five years until Overton was arrested on an unrelated burglary charge in October 1996. Following an attempt to take his own life while in custody, investigators used blood from the attempt to match DNA from semen recovered at the crime scene. At his 1999 trial, prosecutors argued Overton became obsessed with Susan MacIvor after meeting her at a gas station where he worked. Overton has maintained his innocence, claiming the evidence was planted and that he was working at the time of the murders, though he stated his timesheets were lost.
The execution of Thomas Mitchell Overton marks the 20th time Florida has administered the death penalty in 2026. This action affects the survivors of the victims, including Sharon MacIvor, the sister of Michael MacIvor, who stated she would be present for the execution on behalf of her deceased parents. The case has spanned 35 years from the date of the crime to the scheduled date of the sentence's fulfillment.
The case involved decades of litigation and a conviction based on DNA evidence that Overton’s defense continues to challenge. His attorneys have submitted an emergency application for a stay to the U.S. Supreme Court. If the execution proceeds as scheduled at 6 p.m. on November 19, it will involve the use of a three-drug injection protocol.
This case involved the application of DNA evidence in a cold case, as Overton was not a suspect until five years after the murders occurred. The next steps depend on the U.S. Supreme Court's response to the emergency stay request. If the court denies the stay, the execution is scheduled to be completed on Thursday evening. If granted, the execution would be delayed pending further legal review of the claims regarding police conduct and evidence handling.
