A federal judge in San Francisco ruled on Thursday, November 19, 2026, that religious emails sent by U.S. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to agency employees were unconstitutional. U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson determined that the messages violated the First Amendment's establishment clause, which prohibits the government from establishing a religion.
The lawsuit was filed in May 2026 by six employees of the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the National Federation of Federal Employees. The union represents approximately 19,000 workers within the agency. The plaintiffs challenged Rollins' practice of sending Christian-themed messages and images from her official government email account to the USDA’s 100,000 employees on holidays including Easter, Christmas, Thanksgiving, and Independence Day.
Judge Thompson stated that the emails were problematic because of Rollins' position of authority and the use of official resources. The ruling noted that the messages suggested Christianity was the shared faith of all USDA workers and that employees could not realistically opt out of reading communications from their director. The judge found such messages could coerce subordinates to hide their own religious beliefs or feel pressured to adopt the secretary’s faith.
In her order, Thompson specified that Rollins must avoid proselytizing—the act of attempting to convert others to a religion—when communicating with workers. The judge noted that Rollins may still discuss her faith with interested colleagues or share why it is meaningful to her in appropriate conversations. A USDA spokesperson stated that the agency is considering an appeal, describing the ruling as an attempt to "muzzle a Cabinet Secretary."
The legal impact centers on the First Amendment’s establishment clause, which governs the separation of church and state. By citing a USDA policy on workplace religious expression that Rollins herself had adopted, the judge set a precedent that internal agency guidelines must be followed by leadership to avoid creating what the court described as a potentially hostile work environment. The ruling explicitly differentiates between private religious expression among willing colleagues and the use of a high-ranking official's digital pulpit to address a diverse, captive workforce.
What happens next: The USDA has indicated it is reviewing the decision for a potential appeal to a higher court. If the ruling stands, it serves as a directive for current and future agency heads regarding holiday communications and religious neutrality in official correspondence. While the judge's order is effective immediately, an appeal could lead to a stay or a reversal of these restrictions. No specific timeline for the filing of an appeal or subsequent court dates was reported.