The Plain Record

Neutral daily news — clear headlines, complete facts.

Legal

Massachusetts Court to Hold Hearing on Lindsay Clancy Case After Mistrial

Prosecutors in Massachusetts are expected to announce on Monday how they will proceed in the case against Lindsay Clancy following a mistrial.

Published November 16, 2026 at 8:20 AM EST

The short answer

Prosecutors in Massachusetts are expected to announce on Monday how they will proceed in the case against Lindsay Clancy following a mistrial. Prosecutors and defense attorneys are scheduled to appear in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday to determine the next steps in the case of Lindsay Clancy.

Massachusetts Court to Hold Hearing on Lindsay Clancy Case After Mistrial

The Facts

Who
Lindsay Clancy, District Attorney Tim Cruz, Defense Attorney Kevin Reddington, and Judge William Sullivan.
What
Court hearing to determine charges and retrial schedule for Lindsay Clancy.
When
Monday at 10 a.m. ET
Where
Plymouth Superior Court, Massachusetts
Why
To determine if the state will pursue first-degree murder charges again or seek lesser charges following a deadlocked jury in the first trial.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys are scheduled to appear in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday to determine the next steps in the case of Lindsay Clancy. The hearing follows a mistrial declared on Sept. 4 after a jury reached a deadlock regarding charges that Clancy killed her three children.

The case originated from the Jan. 24, 2023, deaths of 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson, and 8-month-old Callan Clancy at their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts. During the initial trial, defense attorney Kevin Reddington acknowledged that Clancy killed the children but argued she was not criminally responsible due to postpartum psychosis and overmedication. Prosecutors argued that Clancy understood her actions and planned the killings.

At the Monday hearing, prosecutors are expected to announce how they plan to proceed. Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz has the option to seek a retrial on the original first-degree murder charges or pursue lesser charges such as second-degree murder or manslaughter. Judge William Sullivan, who is set to retire in June 2027, recently denied a motion to dismiss the murder charges during a Nov. 9 hearing.

Legal analyst Jennifer Roman noted that if prosecutors choose to seek lesser charges like second-degree murder or manslaughter, Clancy would have the option to plead guilty and avoid a trial entirely. However, her attorney has previously stated he would not accept a plea deal that involves jail time.

The outcome of this hearing carries weight for the extended Clancy family and the public, who have followed the case since the January 2023 deaths. A second trial would require selecting a new jury to evaluate evidence regarding mental health and criminal responsibility that previously resulted in a deadlocked panel.

If the case proceeds to a new trial on lesser charges, Clancy would have the legal right to choose between a jury trial or a bench trial, where a judge alone decides the verdict. The specific timeline for a new trial and the final list of charges are expected to be clarified during this court session. Following this hearing, the court will likely set new deadlines for the next phase of the legal process.

Timeline of what happened

Key dates and decisions, in the order they occurred.

  1. January 24, 2023

    Deaths of three Clancy children in Duxbury

  2. September 4, 2024

    Mistrial declared after jury deadlocks

  3. November 9, 2026

    Judge denies motion to dismiss murder charges

Summaries are written by The Plain Record to state the facts of a story plainly and without political slant. Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the source record before publication. See how we report, or report a correction.

← Back to the front page

Questions readers ask

What happened: Massachusetts Court to Hold Hearing on Lindsay Clancy Case After Mistrial?

Prosecutors and defense attorneys are scheduled to appear in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday to determine the next steps in the case of Lindsay Clancy. The hearing follows a mistrial declared on Sept. 4 after a jury reached a deadlock regarding charges that Clancy killed her three children.

Who is involved?

Lindsay Clancy, District Attorney Tim Cruz, Defense Attorney Kevin Reddington, and Judge William Sullivan.

When did this happen?

Monday at 10 a.m. ET

Where did this happen?

Plymouth Superior Court, Massachusetts

Why does this matter?

To determine if the state will pursue first-degree murder charges again or seek lesser charges following a deadlocked jury in the first trial.