The board of directors for the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) has approved the first uniform national guidelines for a procedure used to retrieve organs from deceased donors. The process, known as normothermic regional perfusion (NRP), involves using an external pump to restore blood flow to a donor’s organs minutes after their circulation has ended. The new rules, approved on Nov. 6, are intended to establish safeguards for potential donors while potentially increasing the supply of available organs.
The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), which oversees the transplant system, requested the guidelines following reports of "signs of life" during some NRP procedures. Dr. Claire Morgan, a transplant surgeon, reported cases where blood appeared to reach the brain even after circulation to the head was supposed to have been blocked. According to HRSA, approximately 109,000 Americans are currently waiting for transplants, and about 12 people die daily due to the organ shortage.
The approved guidelines, set to take effect Dec. 6, require surgeons to clamp blood vessels supplying the head and to "vent" or cut those vessels above the clamp. Dr. Raymond Lynch of HRSA stated these steps ensure that oxygenated blood does not reach the brain. The policy also recommends against using drugs that could mask donor movement. Some critics, including Dr. Morgan, argued that these safeguards are insufficient because many surgeons already use these techniques, and they questioned the emergency implementation of the policy before a public comment period.
Ethical concerns regarding NRP center on the "dead donor rule," which states that organs may only be removed after a patient is declared dead by brain or circulatory criteria. Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross, a bioethicist at the University of Rochester, argued that NRP violates this rule by restarting circulation in a patient who was just declared dead due to the end of circulation. Bioethicists like Dr. Matthew DeCamp of the University of Colorado stated that the policy was adopted before fundamental questions about whether these donors are technically dead have been resolved.
The procedure changes the day-to-day experience of transplant surgery and the legal interpretation of death. The requirement to clamp and vent blood vessels to the brain is a technical change designed to ensure the donor does not regain brain function during the process. For families, this means the donor is declared dead by circulatory criteria, but their body is then mechanically supported to keep organs viable. The use of NRP has sparked a debate over whether restarting blood flow reverses the state of death.
The immediate impact will be felt starting Dec. 6, when the first phase of the uniform national guidelines becomes effective. While proponents like Dr. Lynch argue the policy is a necessary step for patient safety and organ supply, critics worry that formalizing the procedure may accelerate its use before ethical debates are settled. The OPTN and HRSA will continue to monitor the implementation. Individuals who are registered organ donors or those making medical decisions for family members will need to be aware of these retrieval methods when consenting to donation.
