New York prosecutors announced this week that David Agtsteribbe, 58, has been arrested for allegedly posing as a decorated combat veteran to steal more than $80,000 from a local American Legion chapter. Agtsteribbe, a resident of Hampton Bays, faces charges including second-degree grand larceny and criminal possession of a forged instrument.
According to the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office, Agtsteribbe joined the Hampton Bays American Legion as a finance officer in 2021. Prosecutors allege he gained the position by providing fraudulent military credentials, including a claim of an honorable discharge and a Purple Heart, an award designated for service members wounded or killed in action.
Military records cited by prosecutors show Agtsteribbe enlisted in the U.S. Army in 1986 but was court-martialed a year later for stealing money from another soldier. He received a bad-conduct discharge in 1988, which the American Legion states would have disqualified him from membership. Agtsteribbe, who has two prior convictions for grand larceny, pleaded not guilty at his Tuesday, Nov. 10, arraignment.
This case affects the members and beneficiaries of the Hampton Bays American Legion, a veterans’ service organization. Prosecutors allege the theft targeted nearly $81,800 between September 2022 and August 2026. Local business owner Simone Scotto noted the organization typically uses its resources to support community programs.
The scale of the alleged theft translates to an average of roughly $1,700 per month diverted over the 47-month period cited by investigators. Veteran Rodney Smith told local media that the loss of these funds impacts the availability of assistance for veterans who require support. The District Attorney's office reported that the funds were instead used for personal expenses, including utility bills, clothing, travel, and online retail purchases.
Agtsteribbe was ordered to remain in custody following his arrest on Monday, Nov. 9. If convicted of the top count of second-degree grand larceny, he faces a maximum sentence of 25 years to life in prison.
