A group of prosecutors and victims' families filed a lawsuit on Monday, November 16, seeking to block California Governor Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute the sentences of all 548 death row inmates to life in prison without parole. The legal challenge, submitted to the California Supreme Court by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, argues the governor overstepped his authority and failed to follow statutory notification procedures.
The lawsuit follows Governor Newsom's announcement on November 5 that he intended to move 529 men and 19 women from death row to permanent life sentences. While California has not conducted an execution since 2006, the death sentences remained active until Newsom issued a moratorium on the practice in 2019. Under the California Constitution, the governor must obtain state Supreme Court approval for clemency in cases where an inmate has been convicted of multiple felonies, a condition that applies to 382 of the current death row inmates.
The plaintiffs, including district attorneys from 30 counties and more than two dozen relatives of murder victims, allege that Newsom did not review inmates' cases individually and failed to provide required notice to prosecutors and families. Anne Marie Schubert, president and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, accused Newsom of allowing personal views to override the decisions of judges and juries. Newsom's office has argued that typical notification rules do not apply in this instance because the governor initiated the process himself rather than responding to petitions from individual prisoners.
Prosecutors argue that the move bypasses the work of thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges across California. The day-to-day change for the affected inmates would be a transfer out of death row housing and the removal of the legal possibility of execution. Families of victims would notice the finality of a life-without-parole sentence, which Newsom acknowledged could bring back painful memories.
The case involves whether a governor can use commutations for an entire class of inmates rather than reviewing cases one by one. It also tests victim notification laws in California. If the court rules against Newsom, he may be forced to restart the process for each of the 548 inmates individually. What happens next depends on the California Supreme Court, which must now decide whether to grant the approval required for the 382 multi-felony offenders. No specific court date has been reported.