Scottish First Minister John Swinney apologized at Holyrood on Thursday following his party’s use of an artificial intelligence-generated video featuring figures in the style of the Grand Theft Auto video game. The Scottish National Party (SNP) deleted the post from Instagram after it drew criticism regarding the technology's environmental and social impacts.
The video was posted to coincide with the release of Grand Theft Auto VI, a product of the Scottish video games industry. The clip, titled "Grand Theft Alba," reportedly depicted an AI-generated Boris Johnson partying with a beer and Baroness Margaret Thatcher emptying a sack of "Scottish oil money" into a barrel marked "UK Treasury."
An SNP spokesperson stated the video was intended to highlight political issues such as energy wealth, independence polling, and the rise of the Reform party. However, the spokesperson noted that the party is discussing the "legitimate use of AI and its limits" and elected to remove the post. During First Minister’s Questions, Scottish Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay questioned whether the government understood concerns regarding the impact of AI on workers, artists, and the environment.
The controversy involves environmental activists and workers in the creative and technology sectors who are concerned about the growth of artificial intelligence. In Scotland, these groups have recently expressed opposition to the expansion of hyperscale data centers. On Saturday, November 14, thousands of protesters, supported by over 80 organizations including trade unions and climate groups, marched through Edinburgh to voice concerns about the energy and water consumption of these facilities.
For the average resident, the growth of this industry could result in changes to local land use and resource management. While First Minister Swinney acknowledged the risks associated with AI data centers, he also pointed to potential benefits in public services. He specifically noted that AI applications are currently being used in the National Health Service (NHS) to assist in identifying cancer risks and improving clinical assessments.
The Scottish Government has not yet provided a specific timeline for new regulations, but Swinney stated that guidance is being developed to address the risks of data centers and broader policy issues. The SNP's decision to delete the promotional video follows a discussion within the party regarding the use of generative AI.
What happens next: The Scottish Government plans to explore the risks of AI data centers in upcoming guidance. No specific date was reported for the release of these guidelines or for further parliamentary votes on AI regulation. Activists continue to call for the government to explain the necessity of these centers following the demonstration at the Scottish Parliament on Saturday, November 14.
