A study released Tuesday by researchers at Harvard University, Dartmouth College, and NWEA suggests that banning student cellphones during the school day may improve academic performance. The research, which focused on schools using locked pouches to secure devices, found that strict bans could help students recover approximately one to two weeks of learning time per year. The study's authors noted that while these improvements are small, they were statistically significant.
The research arrives as educators seek to address a long-term decline in K-12 reading and math scores. According to Harvard’s Tom Kane, U.S. students began losing two to three weeks of learning annually starting around 2013, a trend that predated the COVID-19 pandemic. Data indicates that while fewer than 25% of teens had smartphones in 2011, that figure rose to 95% by 2018, coinciding with achievement drops in the U.S. and other industrialized nations.
The new study analyzed student-level test scores from 844 schools that used lockable pouches manufactured by the company Yondr and administered NWEA tests. The research team tracked more than 3 million students over five school years. The findings indicated that the learning gains associated with the bans did not fade after the first year but persisted for at least three years after adoption.
These findings contrast with a peer-reviewed study released in April by researchers at the University of Michigan and Stanford University. That earlier study, which examined school-level mean scores at several thousand schools, found "close to zero" impact on student test scores. While the April study did find gains in high school math, those were offset by learning losses in middle schools. The researchers from the April study expressed caution regarding the new findings, with Stanford's Tom Dee stating he was uncomfortable extrapolating from estimates that were small and based on a limited number of years.
The policy primarily affects K-12 students, school administrators, and parents. According to the reported data, more than 3,300 schools across the United States adopted locked-pouch systems produced by Yondr between the 2019-2020 and 2025-2026 school years. In a typical implementation, students are required to place their phones in a pouch at the start of the day, which is then sealed and only opened by a school official using a magnetic device at dismissal.
The scale of the reported benefit is approximately 1 to 2 weeks of restored learning per year, which co-author Tom Kane estimates plugs about half of the "slow leak" of learning loss observed since 2013. Economically, the cost of implementing these bans is roughly $25 per student for the pouches. Proponents argue this is less expensive than the cost of paying teachers for additional weeks of instruction to achieve comparable learning gains.
The findings may influence how school boards and state legislatures approach technology policies. While the April study found "meaningful achievement gains" were lacking, the newer study suggests a potential for accumulated benefits over time. However, Dee described current results as "largely disappointing" and emphasized that it is not yet clear if these small gains will aggregate as predicted. Future research is expected to focus on smartphone and social media use outside of school hours.
