The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) moved on a Thursday to effectively end its legal challenge seeking to block the certification of Mary Peltola's victory in the Alaska U.S. Senate race. The administration requested that the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals declare the case moot following the conclusion of the election. This move follows an earlier ruling by a federal judge in Alaska who had dismissed the lawsuit.
The litigation began when the administration sought to investigate potential voter confusion caused by a second candidate on the ballot, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., who shared a name with the incumbent Republican, Sen. Dan Sullivan. While the Alaska Supreme Court had ruled the second Sullivan's candidacy legal, the Trump administration argued certification should be delayed until the DOJ could determine if voters intended to cast ballots for the incumbent.
Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward stated in the filing that the government "reluctantly acknowledges" it can no longer determine voter intent for those specific ballots. The filing follows a report by The New York Times alleging that Peltola's campaign was involved in recruiting the second Sullivan, a retired schoolteacher. Both Peltola and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. have denied these allegations, with Peltola stating she was "not interested in tricking voters."
For voters in Alaska, the resolution means the election results will be certified as cast, despite the presence of two candidates named Dan Sullivan on the ballot. The administration had not specified a mechanism for investigating voter intent given ballot secrecy laws, so the dismissal removes the prospect of individual voters being questioned about their selections. The scale of the victory was reported as an outright majority for Peltola, who received more votes than the combined total of the other candidates, including Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
The case sets a precedent regarding federal intervention in state-run elections over "decoy" candidates. While Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy (R) and the DOJ's top prosecutor in Alaska had called for investigations into the recruitment of the second Sullivan, the federal court's earlier dismissal and the DOJ's subsequent move to drop the appeal signal a conclusion to federal attempts to pause certification. Following this filing, Peltola stated she intends to begin work on behalf of the state immediately, as the legal barriers to her seating have been removed.