Three Chagos Islanders on Friday, November 20, lost a legal bid to challenge the British government over its decision to transfer sovereignty of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. Lady Justice Andrews of the Court of Appeal dismissed the application for an appeal brought by Bertrice Pompe, Michel Mandarin, and Misley Mandarin.
The legal action followed a May 2025 agreement in which the United Kingdom consented to hand over the archipelago to Mauritius. This agreement includes a provision to lease back Diego Garcia, the largest island and site of a military base, to the UK for 99 years. The islanders argued that the Foreign Office failed to consult them regarding a "right of abode" on the islands during the negotiations.
In her 21-page ruling, Lady Justice Andrews described the islanders' argument regarding a duty to consult as "nonsensical" in the context of maintaining the status quo. While acknowledging the claimants' views that the deal was insufficient to protect their interests, the judge concluded that the grounds for appeal did not have a real prospect of success. This follows a March ruling where a judge similarly denied the trio the right to bring a full challenge against the Foreign Office.
The ruling affects the displaced Chagos Islanders, specifically the three named claimants. The decision involves a treaty impacting the British Indian Ocean Territory, which has been under British control since 1965. The deal involves the Chagos archipelago and a 99-year lease of the Diego Garcia military facility. The islanders have noted the lack of a guaranteed "right of abode" in the deal and argued the UK government should have done more to safeguard their interests.
U.S. President Donald Trump called the deal "terrible" and "ridiculous" during a United Nations General Assembly meeting earlier in 2026. This opposition led the UK government to pause progress on legislation related to the treaty in April 2026, stating it could not proceed without American support. Currently, a private members' bill concerning the deal remains at the committee stage.