The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is scheduled to deliver a verdict on Thursday in a genocide case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar. The case centers on the 2017 military operations in Rakhine State that led to the mass displacement of the Rohingya population. While individual defendants have been convicted of genocide in other tribunals, no sovereign state has ever been found guilty of the crime by an international court.
The Gambia filed the case in November 2019 with the support of the Organisation of Islamic Co-operation. The legal action followed a 2018 United Nations report that found Myanmar's military tactics were "grossly disproportionate" to security threats and called for investigations into genocide and crimes against humanity. Myanmar authorities have denied these allegations, characterizing their actions as "clearance operations" targeting Rohingya militants.
To secure a conviction, judges at the ICJ must find that the evidence shows "genocidal intent" was the only reasonable inference from the state's actions. The Gambia's legal team, led by Arsalan Suleman, argued that a history of discriminatory laws—including the 1982 citizenship law and restrictions on healthcare and education—demonstrates this intent. Myanmar’s defense, previously led by Aung San Suu Kyi before she was deposed in a 2021 coup, argued that the military was engaged in a complex internal conflict and that war crimes, if they occurred, do not prove a state policy of genocide.
The scale of the 2017 operations involved the burning of villages and the flight of hundreds of thousands of people into neighboring Bangladesh. A ruling against Myanmar would label the state as a perpetrator of genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. While an ICJ verdict is final and carries no right of appeal, the court lacks a mechanism to enforce penalties. The military government has recently attempted to improve its international standing, though analysts suggest the leadership is focused more on regional Asian relations than on Western critics who are more likely to prioritize the court’s decision.
The long-term effects of the verdict depend on whether other nations use a finding of genocide to coordinate diplomatic or economic pressure to resolve the displacement crisis. Currently, much of the territory in Rakhine State is controlled by the insurgent Arakan Army, and many original Rohingya villages have been destroyed. These factors, combined with hostility from the local Rakhine population, present obstacles to the safe return of refugees. The verdict will be read at The Hague on Thursday; if the state is found responsible, it would be a judgment of landmark importance regarding international legal accountability under the Genocide Convention.
